Poor Man's PTI Wednesday at 8PM ET | July Writing Contest

Display: Sort:
Top 10 Upsets of the Last 28 Years | 9 comments (9 topical, 0 editorial, 0 hidden)
Your years are deceiving you (#1)
by Flemish American on Tue Jan 29 2008 at 6:22 AM EST
In the greater context of things, you pulled out a couple of good hits with your inclusion of Olympic wrestling and the Tyson loss, but you also let yourself get caught up in the modern age a bit too much to quantify your list in a credible fashion.  

The loss of Michigan to Appalachian State was clearly an upset and sportswriters had a field day declaring it the greatest upset in College Football History because that is what they do to sell their pieces, but I'm not so sure they will be saying that even next year.

The fact that Appalachian State is a three-time (consecutive) champion means they have quality and Michigan never should have approached them as an easy victory, despite the division they play in.

Also, an upset indicates winning a game or series against a common opponent.  If you want to say George Mason's win over Connecticut is your upset call I can live with that, but don't label their run in the tournament as an upset.

On a final note; the inclusion of two Olympic events indicates upsets on the world stage, but your article is still ultra American in nature.  You could just have easily included American defeats among your candidates.

I don't want to belittle your research, but I think an older writer with a keen memory over the period since 1980 would make a more credible listing that covers all sports.  It also bothers me that a google search brought me to this article http://espn.go.com/page2/s/list/topupsets/010525.html where your listing is basically a copy of the ESPN Page 2 selections with the last couple of years factored in.

Yes.. (#2)
by JDWC on Tue Jan 29 2008 at 8:27 PM EST
Unfortunately I haven't lived long enough to know enough about more upsets, but I am a big sports fan and these 10 have always been some of my favorites. And I'm not surprised that a lot of them were in that ESPN article because I didn't really go out of my way to pick upsets that most people wouldn't. I wish I had more knowledge of upsets so I could've gone outside the box a bit, but unfortunately, even with the research, I didn't find any I thought should displace my top 10. And I'm also hardly aware of any upsets away from home (America) so I'm sorry for that, it's just how it is.

On another note, the deal with App St. and GM...Yes App St. was a talented D-II team, but they were still D-II and Michigan was a top 5 D-I school. I mean they are Michigan for god's sake. If App St. had beaten Stanford or University of Idaho or something like that it would be different, but it was Michigan...HUGE upset. Especially in the Big House. And I agree, I shouldn't have labeled the entire George Mason run as an upset, but other than their win against Wichita St. I would consider all their wins in that tournament bigtime upsets. I should have put a note in there though, that's my fault.
J.D.
[ Parent ]

Face Value (#4)
by Flemish American on Wed Jan 30 2008 at 3:12 PM EST
I won't hurt your piece anymore with a negative vote, but understand that your inclusion of the same upsets as the ESPN article might be understandable, but the fact that the order of the pre-2004 events was the same still bothers me.

On the other hand, I guess I have to suck it up regarding the Michigan - App St. result.  I'm still trying to convince myself it was a bad dream.

[ Parent ]

Top 10 Upsets of the Last 28 Years | 9 comments (9 topical, 0 editorial, 0 hidden)
Display: Sort:


Login

Create an account

User ID:
Passwd:

Forgot your password?