First off, how could Papelbon win the Cy Young but not Rookie of the Year? And why Verlander over him and Fransico Liriano? Why are Wright and A-Rod out of the starting lineups?

And I don't think Wells is an MVP. The Blue Jays are leading the majors in OPS and batting average, so an MVP can't really come out of their offense.

However, I do agree with many of your other picks. Good job overall.