I agree with some of what you are saying, but the McNair point is ridiculous. The Ravens are better this year because their defense has returned many stars from injury last year (Ray Lewis, Ed Reed), and because other role players on their defense are having career years. McNair has been OK, but hasn't really been the reason for the team's winning. Brees, meanwhile, has more impressive statistics and has turned one of the league's worst offenses into one of its best.

However, especially after last week, I think it would be hard not to give the MVP to Tomlinson.