By this time in his career, John Elway had already been to three Superbowls. And even after playing for twice as many seasons, Elway still had a higher lifetime win percentage than Manning's current rate. So, I think we need a little perspective. Unless Manning manages to roll off five Superbowl appearances -- including two victories -- in the next eight seasons, he still falls in the "most underperforming, overrated chokaholic QB of all-time" category.
Maybe he needs to go to Elway's Colorado Crush in order to learn how to play in big games -- even they have won the title.
Create an account