Jayson Stark of ESPN.com has an interesting question for you.  Over the long run, who will get more home runs in his career? Even though Griffey is only 10 months older, he has a 100 HR lead.  Still, a lot of people seem to think that he can't maintain his good health and Thome might end up surpassing him.  

Still, at this point in time, total HRs aside, do you think Thome is a better player?  With or without a Jevon Kearse size asterisk for "if he stays healthy" next to Griffey's name.