Washington Nationals

Changing Positions Doesn’t Need to Mean a Change of Attitude

by Matt Wells

Imagine this, if you will: you’re doing what you love to do.  You’re getting paid $10 million to perform your dream job.  You’re also one of the best at what you do in your field.

Then, why complain?  Ohhhhh, I get it.  You’re Alfonso Soriano – the Terrell Owens of football.  Soriano has already made Jim Bowden the laughing stock of GMs, the Washington Nationals the laughing stock of the league (for now), and he has made himself the butt of sports jokes everywhere.Alfonso Soriano is a second baseman by trade.  He played second base when he was with the New York Yankees, and he played the same position with the Texas Rangers.

This is the same Alfonso Soriano who averaged over 35 homeruns and 133 RBI over the past 4 seasons, 2 with New York and 2 with Texas.  He was the All-Star Game MVP in 2004.  Soriano is also one of the top second basemen in the game.

So, what’s up with Alfonso Soriano?

Well, Mr. Soriano has been ordered to play left field for the Nats, who are already heavy at the second base position.  Soriano has refused.  That’s right, someone getting paid $10 million to do the “simple” task of playing another position is pouting.  He’s pouting a lot.

It seems that Soriano doesn’t want to play left field.  He wants to play second base, and ONLY second base.  There’s one problem: Washington’s second baseman goes by the name of Jose Vidro.

Now, sure, Vidro was hurt for most of the 2005 campaign.  In years past, however, Vidro put up respectable numbers that peaked in 2000, when he hit 24 homers and drove in 97.  Surely, any major league team that has a hole at second base would love to have a Jose Vidro.

Soriano is implicitly telling Vidro to move his rear and vacate the second base position.  However, Vidro has been in the Expos/Nationals organization since 1997, meaning that the Nationals would probably side with their veteran rather than some newcomer.

Soriano won’t play anywhere but second base; however, other players in the past (on different teams, of course) have been asked to switch positions.  These players switched positions without giving too much lip back to management.

Let’s briefly take a look at 3 players that come to mind in recent baseball history that had to switch positions:

CHIPPER JONES, Atlanta Braves – Chipper, a third baseman by trade, was asked to move to left field for long stints in 2002.  Jones would be an everyday left fielder for the 2002 and 2003 seasons, where he would commit just 7 errors in each season.  For a third baseman, I consider 14 errors in 2 full seasons to be pretty darn good.  Jones’s productivity at the plate wouldn’t be hurt either: he’d hit 53 homers in those two seasons.

TODD HUNDLEY, New York Mets – I felt for Todd Hundley, I really did.  Hundley was one of the more popular Mets back in the late 1990s, especially when he broke the then-record for homeruns by a catcher in a season (41 in 1996).  The Mets needed help in the outfield, and they asked on their catcher to help fill the void.  It was a nightmare for poor Todd Hundley as routine fly balls became adventures.  In 34 games in left field, Hundley committed 5 errors.  If one were to project that out to 162 games (in a season, of course), Hundley would have committed close to 24 errors.  As you all know, 24 errors is a heck of a lot for an outfielder.  Yet, Hundley never lashed out at the Mets management and went out there with a brave face.  Good man.

CHUCK KNOBLAUCH, New York Yankees – Knoblauch was a second baseman, and a darn good one, for the Minnesota Twins before coming to the big apple.  While in New York, Knoblauch’s defensive prowess would steadily decline to the point that throws to first base were adventures.  One throw sailed into the stands and nailed Keith Olbermann’s mother in the head…but, I digress.  Knoblauch was asked to play left field, and he was decent, committing just 5 errors in 182 games over two seasons.  (The second season was spent in Kansas City).  By the way, do you remember why Knoblauch was moved to left field?  IT WAS DONE TO KEEP ALFONSO SORIANO’S BAT IN THE LINEUP.  Can you say “co-in-ced-ence”?

So, Alfonso Soriano was happy to play second base in New York at the expense of Chuck Knoblauch.  It’s about time Soriano should return the favor to someone else. But he’s not willing to do the same thing with Jose Vidro in Washington.  Two words: Grow Up.

Now, some may blame Nationals GM Jim Bowden for not doing his research before acquiring Soriano.  Bowden was so eager to enhance his reputation that he wasn’t listening when Soriano told him that left field wasn’t an option.  This goes under the heading of doing your research first before jumping into something you find exciting and potentially beneficial.

Now, the Nationals are looking to put Soriano on the “disqualified list.”  To steal a line from Jim Rome, this is the “T.O. List” of baseball.  Soriano would not get paid, nor (obviously) would he play.  There’s one thing that’s for sure: Soriano’s mouth would be running more than it is now.  That can’t be good.

It’s time for Soriano to step up to the plate, bite the bullet, and do what he’s told.  Chipper Jones did it.  Todd Hundley did it.  Chuck Knoblauch did it…FOR SORIANO!  Now, it’s your turn, Alfonso.

Stop whining and do what you’re told.  Just shut up and play.

By Matt Wells

27 years old. From New Jersey. I'm a fan of all four major sports, though I know most about football and baseball. Favorite teams: Sabres (NHL), Yankees (MLB). General fan of baseball and football, as well.

13 replies on “Changing Positions Doesn’t Need to Mean a Change of Attitude”

good job In your list of position changes you forgot one of the most obvious ones–A-Rod moving from short to third when he was traded to the Yanks. Anyway, I think that Soriano is disrespecting his organization and management by not switching positions. What an awful role model.

I Knew It I knew I forgot one player.  I had three in mind (with A-Rod being the third) and forgot him, switching to Knoblauch instead.

Good call.

What I don’t get… is that Soriano was a shortstop in the minor leagues who switched to second base (AP), so he’s been through this before. Granted, it’s a little bigger of a switch, but you should want to go where you can help the team the most, right? If he wants his money, he’ll go to LF.

Sori has always been a problem he didnt want to move from SS to 2b in the first place in NY. Why do you think he’s been shipped so easily the past few seasons? NY didn’t accept his poor attitude, and neither did the Rangers.

The best thing Sori refuses not to do is run hard out of the box on a ball he hits pretty good. Happened once again during a Yankee game last season and I remember it distinctivly because he got thrown out trying to stretch it into a double. Had he run hard out of the box, like both the Rangers and Yankees had asked of him, the broadcasters and myself would not have been making fun of his poor attitude and wasted talent.

Knobby used to be my favorite player, even before he came to NY.

As much as I hated seeing him do so poorly in NY then KC, he was always such a key player and hit many clutch homers for the Yanks in the World Series (Game 1 of 98, Game 3 of 99). he also put down an excellent bunt in game 1 of the 99 world series setting up the winning runs, and he had a sac fly in 200 during game 1, scoring Paul O’Neil and sending the game, which the Yanks won again, into extra innings. Let’s not forget he scored the winning run in Game 5 of the 01 WS when Sori had one of the brighter moments of his short and ugly career.

Come on I understand what you guys are saying. I do. And if thi swere any player but Soriano I would back you up all the way. Unfortunatly Soriano is my favorite player. First, I have to say that Soriano was signed to play second base by the Nationals. If there was any questions of what position Soriano was going to be playing it should have been done in the process of signing soriano. So this was  Jim Bowden’s fault. Also, Soriano and the Nationals had to go through arbitration over Soriano’s contract. For those of you who don’t know what goes on in arbitration, it’s basically the player’s manager saying what a great player the player is, and a representitive from the team saying what a bad player the player is to a judge whod decides what the contract will be. Soriano lost in arbitration giving him 2 million dollars less than wanted. So not only did he get told about how horrible of a player he is, but he didn’t even get the ammount of money he wanted. After you heard how bad you are would you really want to help that team. I understand how bad Soriano is at second base, but he was signed to play second base.  Like I said I agree with you guys, but with Soriano I had to stick up for him.

oh yea The T.O. of baseball! What is that? T.O. has caused tons of problems for everybody. Soriano has just made one problem, and it isn’t even close to as bad as some of the things T.O. has done. I hope you were exaggerating.

Well… I actually got the “idea” from Jim Rome and, at the time, I liked what I heard.  Blame Jim Rome, not me.  🙂

The bigger issue I think the main point here should be that Vidro is a way better defensive second baseman. Infact Soriano is one of the worst EVER.

Also, I don’t think you can blame Jim Bowden. When you give a guy 10 million dollars I think you are allowed to assume a couple of things. You should be able to assume that person will be willing to accept pitching if I ask him too…

what ok i know Vidro is a lot better fielding second baseman. But I do think it’s Jim Bowden’s fault for not clarifying what position Soriano would be expected to play. Last, what does that last sentence say. I don’t understand it.

Sorry it’s hard to understand The basic concept of the last sentence is again if I give a guy 10 mil I should be able to put him wherever I want in the field!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *